Home secretary narrows immigration proposals after cabinet and union pushback
Shabana Mahmood reversed part of a planned change to settlement rules, creating a five-year route for care staff while keeping retrospective longer waits for many migrants.

Shabana Mahmood has scaled back the toughest elements of a proposed overhaul of settlement rules after resistance from ministers and health-sector unions, telling MPs that some care workers will be exempt from the strictest measures.
The home secretary abandoned a plan that would have required care workers to wait 15 years before qualifying for indefinite leave to remain. Instead, she announced a specific carve-out enabling care staff — and their dependants — to seek settlement after five years’ residence, a group estimated at around 280,000 people.
Mahmood also told parliament that other migrants would still face retrospective changes under the policy package, with some subject to a revised waiting period of ten years before they could apply for indefinite leave.
Why the change came about
According to the government’s account, the reversal followed a backlash from within the cabinet and vocal opposition from health unions who had warned about the impact of a lengthy delay to settlement for care sector employees. The announcement was framed as a response to those concerns while preserving broader elements of the government’s tougher immigration agenda.
What it means for care workers and others
Care workers in the specified group will be able to apply for settlement after five years rather than being required to remain for a decade or the previously proposed 15 years. The measure also extends eligibility to family members who depend on those care staff.
Other migrants affected by the reforms will face different transitional arrangements; Mahmood informed MPs that many people would encounter a retrospective extension of the qualifying period to ten years. The government has not provided further operational detail in the statements reported so far about which routes or cohorts will fall into each category and how applications will be managed.
Context and potential implications
The home secretary’s partial retreat illustrates tensions inside government over how to combine a headline-grabbing immigration stance with practical workforce needs in sectors reliant on migrant labour. Care providers and unions had argued that a long delay to settlement would undermine recruitment and retention at a time when the adult social care sector is already under strain.
Ministers framed the exception as a targeted measure to avoid damaging the care workforce while maintaining the broader objective of tightening rules. Observers and stakeholder groups are likely to scrutinise forthcoming secondary regulations and guidance to determine how many people will be covered, how dependants will be assessed and how retrospective elements will be applied.
Next steps
Parliamentary scrutiny will continue as details are worked up and laid before MPs. The government’s further publications and statutory instruments will be watched closely by care employers, unions and migrant-rights organisations seeking clarity on eligibility and timelines.
Sources
This story was written from reports by these outlets. Read the originals:
- 1.Guardian UK: Shabana Mahmood softens immigration plans in face of cabinet backlash
- 2.Guardian World: Shabana Mahmood softens immigration plans in face of cabinet backlash
- 3.Guardian Business: Shabana Mahmood softens immigration plans in face of cabinet backlash



