Federal judge tosses Trump’s $10 billion suit against Wall Street Journal and Rupert Murdoch
A federal judge dismissed President Donald Trump’s multibillion-dollar defamation case against The Wall Street Journal and media owner Rupert Murdoch, saying the complaint relied on weak arguments.

A federal judge has thrown out President Donald Trump’s lawsuit seeking roughly $10 billion in damages from The Wall Street Journal and media executive Rupert Murdoch, rejecting claims linked to reporting about Jeffrey Epstein.
The ruling, announced Saturday, ended the president’s bid to hold the newspaper and Murdoch liable over an article that discussed Mr. Trump’s connections to the late financier Jeffrey Epstein. The judge characterized the legal effort as "grasping at straws," according to news organizations that covered the decision.
What the suit alleged
Trump filed the multibillion-dollar complaint in response to reporting in The Wall Street Journal about his relationship with Epstein. The three news outlets covering the dismissal described the suit as seeking about $10 billion in damages. The Journal and Mr. Murdoch were named as defendants in the case.
The coverage of the underlying article varies slightly across reports. Two outlets described the piece as reporting on Mr. Trump’s ties to Epstein; another report referred to an item tied to an Epstein-related birthday book. The reference to a birthday book and that characterization of the item come from MyJoyOnline.
Judge’s reasoning and reaction
In throwing out the complaint, the judge concluded the president’s claims did not meet the legal standards required to proceed. Reporters who covered the decision quoted the judge as saying the lawsuit amounted to "grasping at straws." The ruling was issued in federal court and ends this particular legal challenge unless the plaintiff pursues an appeal.
Why it matters
The decision removes a major civil claim filed by a sitting president against a prominent news organization and its owner, a case that had attracted attention because of the size of the damages sought and the prominence of the parties. The dismissal underscores the legal hurdles plaintiffs face when attempting to bring broad defamation or related claims against news outlets in federal court.
The ruling also touches on reporting about Jeffrey Epstein, whose ties to high-profile figures have been the subject of extensive media coverage. Differences in how outlets describe the specific item at issue — whether a letter, a story about ties, or a birthday book reference — reflect variations in reporting on the case’s factual backdrop.
Next steps
The sources reporting the dismissal did not provide details about whether the plaintiff planned to appeal or the precise legal grounds the judge relied on in a written opinion. Those developments could determine whether the matter returns to court.
For now, the federal judge’s order ends this round of litigation, leaving The Wall Street Journal and Rupert Murdoch free of the $10 billion claim in this case as described by the news reports covering the decision.
Sources
This story was written from reports by these outlets. Read the originals:
- 1.MyJoyOnline: Judge dismisses Trump’s lawsuit against Wall Street Journal over Epstein birthday book
- 2.NPR National: 'Grasping at straws': Judge dismisses Trump suit against Wall Street Journal over Epstein letter
- 3.ABC News US: 'Grasping at straws': Judge dismisses Trump suit against Wall Street Journal over Epstein letter



