Federal High Court says Nasir El-Rufai has case to answer in phone‑tapping trial
A Federal High Court in Abuja has dismissed a no‑case submission by former Kaduna governor Nasir El‑Rufai and ordered him to enter his defence in a trial over alleged interception of the NSA's phone communications.

A Federal High Court in Abuja on Monday dismissed a no‑case submission by former Kaduna State governor Nasir El‑Rufai and ruled that he has a case to answer in a trial over allegations of phone‑tapping involving the National Security Adviser, Nuhu Ribadu.
The court's decision means El‑Rufai may now choose whether to open his defence in the matter. Multiple reports said the ruling requires the former governor to enter his defence in the proceedings.
What the court decided
The dismissal of the no‑case submission was reported by several outlets, which said the judge found the prosecution had presented sufficient evidence to require El‑Rufai to respond to the charges. Reports identify the accused as standing trial over an allegation that he unlawfully intercepted telephone communications of the NSA, Nuhu Ribadu.
One report named Justice Joyce Abdulmalik as the judge who delivered the ruling.
Prosecution and allegations
According to one outlet, the Department of State Services (DSS) is prosecuting the case. Media accounts say the allegation concerns unlawful interception of the NSA's phone calls, but they do not report a verdict on the underlying charge; the court's ruling concerns only whether the prosecution's evidence was adequate to proceed to the defence stage.
Why this matters
The ruling advances the trial to a more substantive phase by allowing the defence to present witnesses and evidence. It also signals that, at least for now, the court considers the prosecution's case sufficiently pleaded and substantiated to put the accused to his defence.
Conflicting or single‑source details
Not all reports provided the same level of detail. While several outlets described the court as dismissing El‑Rufai's no‑case application and ordering him to enter his defence, only one named the presiding judge and identified the DSS as the prosecuting agency; those details are attributed to that report.
Next steps
With the court having ruled the case should proceed, the next stage is for El‑Rufai to decide whether to call witnesses and make his legal defence. Media accounts did not specify a new trial date or whether El‑Rufai had indicated how he would proceed.
The matter remains before the Federal High Court in Abuja, where the proceedings will determine whether the charges of unlawful interception of communications will be proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
Sources
This story was written from reports by these outlets. Read the originals:
- 1.Premium Times: Court rules El-Rufai has case to answer in phone-tapping trial
- 2.Punch: JUST IN: Court orders El-Rufai to enter defence in wiretapping trial
- 3.Vanguard: Phone-tapping charge: Court rejects El-Rufai’s no-case submission
- 4.Daily Post: Phone-tapping: Court orders El-Rufai to defend himself



