AI bots generated three-quarters of responses in 2023 UK disposable vapes consultation
Research finds tens of thousands of machine-generated submissions flooded a 2023 government consultation on a proposed ban on disposable vapes, in what is believed to be the first coordinated AI attempt to disrupt UK health policymaking.

Research has found that artificial intelligence–generated responses made up about three-quarters of submissions to the UK government’s 2023 consultation on a proposed ban on disposable vapes. Tens of thousands of the responses were identified as machine-generated in what researchers describe as a coordinated attempt to oppose the bill.
The consultation formed part of the legislative process for the tobacco and vapes bill, which included measures to restrict or ban disposable vapes. According to the research, the campaign of automated responses sought to influence the outcome by overwhelming the consultation with fake submissions. The effort ultimately failed to stop the bill from progressing.
Why researchers flag this as significant
Observers described the episode as likely the first coordinated use of AI to target UK health policymaking. The scale of the machine-generated material raised concerns about the vulnerability of public consultations to automated manipulation. Government consultations are intended to gather evidence and public views to inform ministers and lawmakers; researchers say large volumes of inauthentic input can distort that process and make it harder to assess genuine public opinion.
Implications for future consultations and policy
The finding highlights a new vector for attempts to influence democratic and policy processes using generative tools. Because the campaign produced tens of thousands of responses, it illustrates how relatively low-cost automated techniques can create the appearance of mass opposition or support. That creates pressure on officials and could complicate efforts to use consultations as a transparent mechanism for policymaking.
The research noted the campaign did not ultimately prevent the bill from passing through the legislative process. Still, the incident has prompted calls for scrutiny of consultation procedures and for safeguards to detect and mitigate automated interference. It also raises questions about how governments should adapt vetting and verification methods in the age of accessible generative AI.
What is known and what remains open
The analysis determined the majority of submissions were machine-generated and that the operation appeared coordinated in its aim to oppose the disposable vapes ban. Beyond that, the reporting does not identify specific actors behind the campaign or detail the tools used to generate the responses. Researchers framed the episode as a warning signal about how AI could be used in future attempts to influence public policy.
As governments and public bodies update digital engagement practices, this case is likely to be cited in discussions about balancing open consultation with protections against automated manipulation. The episode demonstrates the practical challenges that generative AI poses for maintaining the integrity of public input into health and other policy areas.
Sources
This story was written from reports by these outlets. Read the originals:
- 1.Guardian Business: AI bots flooded 2023 UK government consultation on disposable vapes ban
- 2.Guardian UK: AI bots flooded 2023 UK government consultation on disposable vapes ban
- 3.Guardian World: AI bots flooded 2023 UK government consultation on disposable vapes ban



